WTI's whipsaw between Hormuz deal headlines and tanker incident headlines is the availability heuristic playing out in real time, and it is not settling anything for clients trying to read the trend.

Financials have gained 22% since the war began in February while materials fell 25%. The rotation behind that split, not Wednesday's single session, is what built the TSX's record, and Thursday's oil whipsaw shows the war that caused it hasn't actually ended.

Markets have priced steady de-escalation. A nearly identical arrangement collapsed three weeks ago, and Wednesday brought both a Houthi tanker attack and an Iranian statement that the strait stays closed until the US ends its blockade.

Every major index closed higher Wednesday on Hormuz de-escalation hopes, but gold's largest single-session gain of the week and oil's near-flat close tell a more cautious story than the record headlines do.

The composite gained 1.63% Tuesday on Hormuz optimism, but the sector-level data shows two different markets trading inside the same session: materials up 4.7% on a safe-haven gold rally, energy down as WTI fell 6.36% on the identical headline.

Tuesday's TSX rally and 6.36% WTI decline priced Hormuz optimism as though the strait were reopening. What Iranian, American, and Omani officials are actually describing is a temporary, Iran-administered corridor with a stated one-to-three-month shelf life, and the two sides do not agree on its terms.

Investors are pricing the latest Strait of Hormuz breakthrough as a first event. The 2026 record shows announced de-escalations in this conflict have a short and measurable half-life, and the research on base-rate neglect explains exactly why that record is not being used.

The TSX gained more in one Tuesday session than it lost all of Friday, and gold did the heavy lifting again. But the Government of Canada bond curve eased instead of rising, and the loonie could not hold Friday's level, which is the more useful signal for what happens at the Bank of Canada's September 2 decision.

Trump called off what he described as the biggest strike on Iran since World War Two, then reissued an ultimatum within a day. The chain from that whiplash to Canadian portfolios runs through gasoline prices and the Bank of Canada's September 2 decision as much as through crude oil charts.

Crude has reversed sharply four times in the past month, each time on a headline that got priced as resolution and then was not. The pattern has a name, and it explains why Tuesday's rebound should not be read as an answer either.

A week spent showing Hormuz traffic recovering and the Bank of Canada holding steady ended with tanker strikes, a 19-year Treasury yield high, and a TSX decline that tracked neither.

On July 8, twenty-one days after the memorandum that defined June, the United States and Iran resumed open conflict. WTI round-tripped from a five-month low back above eighty-five dollars, Warsh's Fed sent long yields to a nineteen-year high, and the Strait of Hormuz closed the month at its worst traffic reading of the war.

The TSX, the S&P 500, oil and the Canadian dollar all finished higher Friday. Gold, the number both the Behavioural and Tax and Wealth Desks led with this morning, was the exception, and the vessel data the Geopolitical Desk cited as evidence of calm reversed just as fast.

Fourteen vessels crossed the strait Wednesday without a political settlement behind them. The gap between operational improvement and an actual deal is where the risk to Canadian energy portfolios is sitting right now.

The US paused strikes overnight and Iran and Oman are still nowhere near a deal on the strait. Two commodities read the same week two different ways.

The VIX gave back the entirety of Wednesday's Fed-and-Iran shock in a single session. The market pricing an actual rate decision did not follow it down.